baseball · Pittsburgh Pirates · P · age 24 · about six months
This is the baseball entry for Paul Skenes Y1-Y2 Peak (Sell): P for Pittsburgh Pirates, age 24. It sits alongside 81 other player entries in the picks tool.
Accessibility lands mid-table at 42. The obvious cards have moved, but there are still parallels and lesser versions priced sensibly if you're willing to hunt. That hunting is where the actual work of this one sits.
Breakout (55) runs well ahead of card upside (35), and that gap is deliberate rather than sloppy. It says the performance is more likely than the price reaction. Players get better without their cards noticing all the time — small market, unglamorous position, highlights that don't travel.
Set against the 14 baseball breakout picks scored here, its breakout of 55 ranks 10th of 14, card upside 35 ranks 14th, accessibility 42 ranks 10th, and risk 48 is the 12th-lowest. The closest thing to it on the numbers is Shohei Ohtani Historic-Season Peak (Sell), which scores 55 and 38 on the same two axes — if you're weighing one against the other, the difference is in the reasoning rather than the scores.
The window is about six months. Long enough that one bad month doesn't settle it, short enough that you're betting on a specific stretch rather than a career. Six-month positions are where people most often forget they set a deadline.
Risk at 48 is the middle of the range: real ways to fail, none of them exotic. A role change, a slow start, or the hobby simply deciding to care about something else for a while.
Every entry gets four separate scores instead of one grade, because a single grade hides the thing you needed. Full explanation in the guide: how to spot a breakout before the cards move.
Or browse all breakout picks · how these scores are built